How States and Towns Raise Money
States and towns raise money through sales taxes, property taxes, income taxes, and federal grants, and the mix differs sharply from state to state.
Reading
0%
Time left
~14 min
Quiz score
0/4
What this means
The federal government is not the only government that taxes you. Your state does, your county probably does, and your city or town almost certainly does. They just use different tools, and unlike the federal government, they do not all use the same ones.
The most visible is the sales tax. Buy something at a store and the total at the register is higher than the sticker price; the difference is usually state and local sales tax. You have been paying this tax since you were old enough to buy candy.
The one that funds your school is probably the property tax. Homeowners pay it based on what their property is worth, and renters pay it indirectly because landlords build it into rent. Property tax is overwhelmingly local, and in most places it is the biggest single source of money for public schools.
Many states also collect a state personal income tax, which comes out of paychecks the same way the federal one does. But not all of them do. A handful of states collect no broad personal income tax at all, and a couple collect no general sales tax.
The fourth major source surprises people: federal grants. A large share of state budgets is money from Washington, sent for health care, transportation, and education. State governments do not raise all their own money, and this is why the federal budget and your state budget are connected.
The headline of this benchmark is the variation. There is no single American tax system. There are fifty state systems plus thousands of local ones, and they look genuinely different from each other.
Why it matters
These are the taxes closest to your daily life. The federal budget is enormous and distant; property and sales taxes pay for the road outside your house, the library card in your wallet, and the teacher in front of you.
The variation matters too. When a family moves across a state line, their entire tax picture can change: no income tax here, higher property tax there, sales tax on groceries in one state and not the next. Adults make real decisions based on this, and the trade-offs are rarely as simple as one state being cheaper than another.
Real-world example
Look at a receipt from a store near you and find the sales tax line. Then find the tax rate and check how it splits between your state and your city or county. In many places the posted rate is a state rate plus a local add-on, which is why the rate can change when you drive twenty minutes. Some states also exempt groceries or medicine from sales tax while taxing everything else. Find out whether yours does.
Try it
- Find your state's budget. Search for your state name plus "budget" or "revenue report." Most states publish an annual summary aimed at the public.
- List every revenue source you can find, then group them: sales taxes, personal income taxes, corporate taxes, federal grants, fees and licenses, and everything else.
- Estimate each as a share of the total and make a bar chart. Bar charts work better than pie charts here because you are going to compare states next.
- Now do the local level. Find your city, town, or county budget and identify its revenue sources. Then find your school district's budget and determine what share comes from local property taxes versus the state.
- Do the spending side. List the biggest categories your state and your locality spend on. You will see education, health, transportation, and public safety near the top.
- Compare with a partner who researched a different state, or pick a contrasting state yourself. Choose one with no personal income tax and compare its revenue mix with yours.
- Answer this in writing: if a state collects no personal income tax, where does the money come from instead? Every state has to fund schools and roads somehow, so trace where the burden shifts.
- Final question, and take it seriously: which residents pay the most under your state's mix, and which pay the least? Consider a renter, a homeowner, a retiree with no wages, and a family that spends most of its income on taxed goods.
Teacher note
Step 7 is the analytic heart of this lesson. Students often conclude that a state without an income tax is simply a low-tax state, and the corrective is to have them find that state's sales tax rate, property tax levels, or severance taxes on natural resources. The lesson is not that one arrangement is better; it is that the money has to come from somewhere and different mixes shift the burden onto different people. Step 8 makes that concrete without requiring students to adopt a position, and it works best if you assign each group a specific household to reason about rather than asking abstractly. Two misconceptions to expect. First, students think renters do not pay property tax; walk through how a landlord's costs enter rent. Second, students assume schools are funded federally; the federal share of K-12 funding is small compared with state and local sources, and finding their own district's breakdown in step 4 settles it faster than any explanation. This lesson can drift into arguments about whether the state is overtaxing or underfunding. Redirect to the descriptive question, which is what the mix is and who bears it, and acknowledge that what the mix should be is a genuine political disagreement that this lesson deliberately does not settle. A student has it when they can name their own state's top two revenue sources and explain why a state with no income tax is not automatically a low-tax state.
Check yourself
Which of these is typically the largest source of funding for local public schools?
A state collects no personal income tax. What is most likely true about that state?
A large share of your state government's budget comes from money sent by the federal government. What is this called?
Why does the sales tax rate sometimes change when you drive a short distance?
State and local governments fund themselves with a mix of sales, property, and income taxes plus federal grants, and because every state chooses a different mix, the same family can face very different tax bills depending on where they live.